The House of Representatives has voted out a bill seeking to
limit the category of litigations that can be appealed at the Supreme Court.
The bill was to reduce the workload on the apex court, thereby fast tracking
justice delivery.
Critics of the bill, however, argued that the proposed
amendment to the Constitution would be counterproductive as it might lead to
justice denial to would-be litigants.
At the plenary on Thursday, the House considered for second
reading, ‘A Bill for An Act to alter the provisions of the Constitution of the
Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999; the Constitution of the Federal Republic of
Nigeria (First Alteration) Act, 2010; and the Constitution of the Federal
Republic of Nigeria (Second Alteration) Act, 2010, to make appeals to the
Supreme Court to be by leave in order to reduce workload on the court, expedite
hearing and determination of appeals, and encourage efficiency and quality; and
for related matters.’
Chairman of the House Committee on Judiciary, Onofiok Luke,
who sponsored the bill, said its objectives were to expedite hearing and
determination of both civil and criminal matters and appeals by the Supreme
Court; eliminate unnecessary delay in justice delivery and administration by
the Supreme Court; and expedite justice dispensation and boosts people’s
confidence in the judiciary.
Luke further said the proposed amendment would save
litigants from unnecessary and avoidable costs, delays and pains; encourage
foreign investment and bolster economic development; stabilise the polity and
reduce the risk of citizens, residents and investors resorting to self-help;
and encourage sound decisions and grant the Supreme Court room to focus on its
primary duty of legal policy formulations.
He said, “The slow pace of justice delivery in Nigeria,
occasioned partly by excessive workload on the Supreme Court, is a serious
problem which hinders easy and speedy access to justice, and it requires
drastic, urgent solutions.
“This bill provides the needed solution by limiting the
appeals that reach the apex court. Something must be done about the pace of our
justice delivery so that we do not have a situation where the people will
entirely lose faith in our justice system and resort to self-help.”
The lawmaker noted that the jurisdiction of the Supreme
Court is unlimited, expanding to all cases ranging from different areas of law
including constitutional, electoral, administrative, tax, entertainment,
copyright and labour laws.
He also noted that the Constitution pegs membership of the
court at 21 and the court has not since its inception reached its full
membership complement. “At the moment, the court is composed of only just 18
justices. It is these 18 justices that handle all appeals and deliver justice
to the population of over 201 million Nigerians,” he said.
The lawmakers were, however, divided on the bill. While
those who spoke admitted the good intention of the sponsor, they warned that it
might eventually lead to the breach of the rights of Nigerians to seek redress
in any court.
The Deputy Minority Leader, Toby Okechukwu, said it was
understandable that Luke, as chairman of the judiciary committee, would seek a
better justice system. “We also have to juxtapose that with the need to look at
other alternatives to encourage efficiency,” he added.
Okechukwu stated that there were “prudent alternatives”
regarding reduction of workload on Supreme Court justices. He cited the example
of parliamentary election matters where the “Appeal Court becomes the Supreme
Court for that purpose.” He also said cases could be categorised based on the
weight of their penalties.
The lawmaker said, “We may not know the real legal issue to
be determined in any matter. For example, for close to 30 to 50 years, a matter
of inheritance regarding women in Igboland was subject to adjudication – for a
long time. I think about last year or two, the Supreme Court ruled that it
offends the fundamental rights of women for them to be discriminated against in
matters of inheritance.”
Click to signup for FREE news updates, latest information and hottest gists everyday
Advertise on NigerianEye.com to reach thousands of our daily users
No comments
Post a Comment
Kindly drop a comment below.
(Comments are moderated. Clean comments will be approved immediately)
Advert Enquires - Reach out to us at NigerianEye@gmail.com